Selling

Selling Used Underwear and Socks on Reddit vs a Dedicated Marketplace: An Honest Comparison

Reddit is free and busy, but it is also public and unprotected. Here is a fair, plain-English comparison of selling used underwear and socks on Reddit versus a dedicated marketplace.

A laptop, a phone, a small padlock, a plain mailer and folded white sports socks on a wooden desk

Can you sell used underwear on Reddit? Yes. Plenty of adults do, and there are communities set up for exactly that. It is free, the audience is huge, and you can start the same day. For getting seen and learning how this world works, Reddit is hard to beat.

Is it the safest place to sell? No. Your posts are public, nobody checks who the buyers are, and every payment happens somewhere else with nothing to back you up. A dedicated marketplace costs money but gives you privacy, checked buyers and proper selling tools. Many sellers end up using both: Reddit for visibility, a marketplace for the actual sales. The rest of this guide explains why, for men and women alike.

How selling on Reddit actually works

Reddit is not a shop. It is a giant collection of forums, each one run by volunteer moderators with their own rules. Some of those communities exist for adults who want to buy and sell worn items such as underwear, socks, gym kit and shoes.

The process is simple. You make an account, find communities that allow selling, and read their rules. Most ask you to verify in some way, often with a photo holding a handwritten note showing your username. Then you post what you have, usually with a photo and a short description.

Buyers reply in the comments or message you privately. You agree a price, they pay you through a payment app or another method you both choose, and you post the item. That is it. Reddit plays no part in the sale itself. It does not take payment, hold money, track orders or step in if something goes wrong.

That last point matters more than anything else in this guide. Reddit gives you a noticeboard. Everything after the notice is down to you.

What Reddit is genuinely good for

It would be unfair to pretend Reddit has nothing going for it. It has a lot.

  • It is free. No membership, no commission, no listing fees.
  • The audience is enormous. People who want to buy worn items are already there, looking.
  • There are communities for almost every niche, so if you want to sell used socks on Reddit, or panties, boxers or gym kit, there is likely a group for it.
  • You can build a following. Regular posters get known, and known sellers get repeat buyers.
  • It is a brilliant place to learn. You can see how experienced sellers word their posts, what they charge and what buyers ask for.
  • You can start today with nothing more than a phone.

If you are brand new and simply want to understand the market, spending a week reading these communities is time well spent. You will learn what sells, what a fair price looks like and what buyers expect.

The privacy problem: everything is public

Here is the first real downside. Reddit is open to the whole internet. Anyone can read your posts without even having an account. That includes buyers, but it also includes colleagues, family, neighbours and anyone else who stumbles across them.

Your posts can also show up in search engines. And every account has a history. Anyone who clicks your username can see what you have posted and commented on, in every community, going back as far as the account does.

That is where people get caught out. A seller uses an old account, forgets they once mentioned their town, their job or their football team, and suddenly a stranger can piece together who they are. Small details add up fast.

Photos carry risk too. A public photo can be saved, copied and reposted by anyone. Once it is out there, you cannot pull it back.

Tip: If you sell on Reddit, make a brand-new account used for nothing else. New username, new email address, no links to your personal life at all.

Is it safe to sell on Reddit? The buyer problem

Reddit does not check who anyone is. There is no ID check and no age check on buyers. An account takes a minute to make, and a banned or blocked person can simply make another one.

Some communities do their own basic checks, and good moderators work hard. But they are volunteers with limited tools. They cannot confirm a buyer's identity, and they cannot stop someone messaging you privately.

In practice this means you never really know who you are talking to. Most people are genuine. Some are not. And when someone behaves badly, there is very little holding them to account, because they can vanish and come back under a new name.

Payments happen elsewhere, with no safety net

Because Reddit is not a marketplace, money changes hands off the platform. Usually that means a payment app or bank transfer agreed in private messages.

This is where most problems happen. There is no order record, no dispute process and nobody to complain to. If a buyer does not pay, or pays and then claws the money back, Reddit will not help. The payment app may not help either. Many payment services have rules against this kind of sale, so sellers can find their accounts limited or closed, sometimes with money still inside.

There is also a privacy catch. Some payment apps show your real name to the person paying you. Check exactly what a buyer will see before you share any payment details.

Common Reddit scams and red flags

Scams are not unique to Reddit, but an open platform with no checks makes them easier. These are the ones sellers run into most.

  • Fake payment screenshots. The buyer sends a picture that looks like proof of payment and asks you to post straight away. The money never arrives. Only trust what shows in your own account.
  • The reverse "pay me first" trick. Someone claims you need to pay a small fee, a deposit or a "verification charge" before they can send your money. Real buyers never ask sellers to pay them.
  • Free photo hunters. They ask for "just one more picture" or a free preview to prove the item is real. They never intended to buy. Your verification post is the proof.
  • Chargebacks. The buyer pays, receives the item, then tells their bank or payment app the payment was not authorised. The money is taken back from you.
  • Overpayment. A buyer "accidentally" sends too much and asks you to refund the difference. The original payment later bounces.
  • Pressure and rushing. Anyone pushing you to act quickly, move to a different app or skip your usual steps is worth slowing down for.
  • Endless chatters. Not a scam exactly, but people who want hours of free conversation and never order cost you real time.

A simple rule protects you from most of this: payment first, cleared and visible in your own account, before anything is posted or any extra photo is sent. We go deeper in our guide to avoiding scams when buying and selling worn underwear.

Tip: A screenshot is not a payment. Log in to your own account and check the money is really there before you do anything else.

Rules, removals and bans

Every community on Reddit sets its own rules, and they differ a lot. One group wants a verification photo in a set format. Another limits how often you can post. Another bans certain words, links or types of item. Reddit also has its own site-wide rules on top.

Break a rule by accident and your post is removed. Do it more than once and you may be banned from that community. In the worst case an account can be suspended altogether.

For a seller, that is a real business risk. Your followers, your post history and your reputation all sit on an account that can be taken away. Communities themselves can also change their rules or close. You do not own any of it.

The answer is not to dodge the rules. It is to read them properly before every first post, follow them, and avoid keeping your whole business in one place.

No shop tools: reviews, menus and orders

Reddit was built for conversation, not selling. So the things you would expect from a shop are missing.

  • No built-in reviews. Some communities keep their own review threads, but there is no rating attached to a buyer or seller that follows them around.
  • No price menu. You type your prices into each post or repeat them in every message.
  • No order tracking. You keep your own notes on who paid, what they ordered and what has been posted.
  • No proper profile or shop page. Old posts sink quickly, so you have to keep posting to stay visible.
  • No custom-order system. Requests arrive as messages and you organise them yourself.

None of this makes selling impossible. It just means more admin, more repeated messages and more room for mix-ups.

How a dedicated marketplace is different

A dedicated marketplace is built for this one job. General selling sites are not an option here. eBay and Vinted do not allow used underwear, which we explain in can you sell used underwear on Vinted. So specialist sites exist to fill the gap, and you can compare what to look for in our guide to the best sites to sell used underwear.

Since this is our blog, we will describe how Scent From Me works. Other marketplaces vary, so always check the details before you join one.

Scent From Me is members-only. Every buyer and every seller passes an ID and age check before they can see anything. Profiles and listings are only visible to verified members, so nothing is public and nothing can be found through a search engine.

Sellers get a profile, listings, a price menu, built-in messaging, reviews and custom-order requests. When you accept an order, you add the postage. There are separate men's and women's sides, and the site is open to verified adults in most countries, including the UK and the US. Explicit photos are not allowed, which keeps things tasteful.

The trade-off is cost. Reddit is free. Scent From Me charges a flat membership of £12.99 a month for Seller or £24.99 a month for Seller Pro, with 6-month options available. There is no commission, so you keep 100% of every sale.

One honest point on payments. On Scent From Me, buyers pay sellers directly, just as they do on Reddit. We do not hold money or sit in the middle of the payment. The difference is who you are dealing with: a buyer who has passed an ID and age check, has a profile and reviews, and is messaging you inside the site. You should still wait for payment to clear before you post anything.

Reddit vs marketplace for selling used underwear: side by side

Here is the comparison in one place, using Scent From Me as the marketplace example.

  • Privacy. Reddit posts are public and tied to a username history anyone can read. On Scent From Me, only verified members can see your profile and listings.
  • Buyer checks. Reddit has no ID or age checks. On Scent From Me, every member is checked before they see anything.
  • Payments. On both, the buyer pays you directly. Neither one holds the money for you. The marketplace difference is that the buyer is verified and has a review history.
  • Fees. Reddit is free. Scent From Me is a flat monthly membership with no commission.
  • Reviews. Reddit has none built in. A marketplace attaches reviews to buyers and sellers.
  • Custom orders. On Reddit you manage requests through messages. A marketplace has a custom-order system and a price menu.
  • Audience. Reddit's audience is far bigger. A marketplace audience is smaller, but everyone there has signed up, been checked and come to buy or sell.
  • Effort. Reddit needs regular fresh posts, rule-checking for every community and lots of message sorting. A marketplace listing stays up and does more of the admin for you.
  • Control. A Reddit post can be removed or an account banned with little warning. On a marketplace, your shop is the whole point of the site.

Neither option wins every row. Reddit wins on cost and reach. A marketplace wins on privacy, trust and tools.

Using both together, safely

Lots of sellers do not pick one. They use Reddit to be seen and a marketplace to sell. That can work well, as long as you do it properly.

Start by reading each community's rules on links and advertising. Some allow you to mention where else you sell. Some do not allow it at all. If the rules say no, respect that. Never spam, and never hide a link or disguise what it is. Be open about where it leads.

Keep the same seller name in both places if you want people to find you, but keep both well away from your real identity. Then let each place do what it is good at. Reddit is where people discover you and get a feel for your style. The marketplace is where the order, the messages and the review all sit in one place.

It also spreads your risk. If a post is removed or a community changes its rules, your shop and your regular buyers are still there.

Tip: Before you mention any other site in a community, check its rules on links. If you are unsure, ask the moderators first. It takes two minutes and can save your account.

Protecting your privacy wherever you sell

Whichever route you choose, the same habits keep you safe.

  • Use a separate seller name and a separate email address that have nothing to do with your real life.
  • Keep your face, tattoos, birthmarks and anything recognisable out of photos. Our guide to listing photos without showing your face shows how.
  • Check the background of every photo for post, windows, uniforms or anything that gives away where you live or work.
  • Never give out your home address, workplace or personal social media accounts.
  • Find out what name a buyer will see when they pay you, before you share payment details.
  • Post items in plain packaging with no description of the contents on the outside. See how to package and post worn items discreetly.
  • Stay polite but firm. You never owe anyone free photos, free chat or an explanation.
  • Block and report anyone who makes you uncomfortable. Trust your gut.

For a fuller checklist, read our guide to staying safe selling worn underwear online.

So which should you choose?

It depends on what matters most to you.

If you want to test the water for free, do not mind putting in daily effort and are confident keeping your identity locked down, Reddit is a fair place to start. Go in with your eyes open, take payment first and treat every stranger as unverified, because they are.

If privacy is your main worry, or you would rather not have anything public at all, a members-only marketplace suits you better. The same goes if you want reviews, a price menu and orders kept tidy without building it all by hand.

And if you want both reach and safety, use both. That is what many experienced sellers settle on.

Getting started on Scent From Me

If a private, members-only setup sounds right, here is how to begin with us. Read how it works first, then look at the membership options and pick Seller or Seller Pro. You will complete an ID and age check, then set up your profile, your price menu and your first listings.

It is open to men and women. There are separate sides for each, so whether you want to sell used panties, sell worn socks or sell worn boxers, your listings sit in front of the right buyers.

We will not promise you instant sales. No honest site can. What we can say is that every person who sees your profile has been ID and age checked, nothing you list is public, and every pound a buyer pays is yours to keep.

Ready to try it? Start here: sell used underwear on Scent From Me.

Thinking of selling? Read our guides on how to sell used men's underwear, how to sell used panties and how to sell worn socks online.

Frequently asked questions

Can you sell used underwear on Reddit?

Yes. Adults can sell worn underwear in Reddit communities that allow it, as long as they follow that community's rules and Reddit's own rules. Reddit only hosts the post, so payment and postage are arranged privately between you and the buyer.

Is it safe to sell on Reddit?

It can be done safely, but the risks are real. Posts are public, buyers are not ID or age checked, and payments happen off the platform with no protection. A separate account, payment up front and careful photos reduce the risk a lot.

How do you sell used socks on Reddit?

Make a new account, find communities that allow sock sales, read their rules and complete any verification they ask for. Then post a clear photo with a short description and price, and take payment before you post the item.

Can you sell used panties on Reddit without showing your face?

Yes. Most sellers never show their face. Crop it out, hide tattoos and other marks, and check the background of every photo before you post it.

What are the most common scams when selling on Reddit?

Fake payment screenshots, buyers who ask you to pay a fee first, people fishing for free photos, and chargebacks after the item has arrived. Always check the money in your own account before you send anything.

Does Reddit charge fees to sell used underwear?

No. Posting on Reddit is free and it takes no commission, because it is not a marketplace. The cost is your time and the lack of protection.

Where can you sell used underwear safely?

A members-only marketplace that checks the ID and age of every buyer and seller is the safer choice for most people. On Scent From Me, profiles and listings are only visible to verified members, so nothing is public.

Is Reddit or a marketplace better for selling used underwear?

Reddit is better for free reach and building a following. A dedicated marketplace is better for privacy, checked buyers, reviews and order tools. Many sellers use both.